Skip to content

Architecture

Neuroaesthetics /1

· Automatically translated from Italian

Marco Carli


Bees love flowers. And women love flowers too, and it’s unlikely you’ll find many people who genuinely believe that flowers are ugly. So, are flowers beautiful to everyone? What about sunsets? Waterfalls? Is there something in our world that can be universally defined as beautiful, something that our brains can recognize as beautiful regardless of cultural and personal influences?

The answer is far from simple. Without delving into the complexities of what constitutes beauty and how art attempts to capture it (a topic that could be discussed for hours, exploring whether it truly captures it or not), are there neurological rules of beauty? Some scientists, a relatively small number, have explored the field of Neuroaesthetics, and they seem to have found some evidence suggesting that our brains recognize certain elements as universally beautiful. The purpose of appreciating beauty from a biological perspective is another matter entirely, a topic that is even more complex and mysterious.

Vilayanur Ramachandran, one of the leading experts in the field, has identified 7 universal principles. One of these is the aversion to coincidences. Imagine drawing two hills in the background and a palm tree in the foreground. The palm tree could, of course, be placed anywhere in the scene. However, if we place the palm tree directly in the center, between the two hills, we tend to feel a sense of unease with the resulting image. If we consider the scene as a real-world scenario, we realize that the image of the palm tree in the center would only be possible from a single viewpoint, which is the coincidence. In contrast, a palm tree that is off-center suggests multiple possible viewpoints. Therefore, images with a randomly placed palm tree are much more common in our experiences. An image with a palm tree in the center is a suspicious coincidence, and the brain always tries to find another, more general and plausible interpretation to avoid the coincidence. If it cannot find such an interpretation, the image feels unpleasant.

Consider the famous optical illusion of three black circles, each missing a segment, which appear to describe a triangle. In reality, there is no triangle, but we perceive one. This is because the brain becomes suspicious of the coincidence of the three circles being arranged randomly in that specific way, and it decides that it is more plausible that there is a white triangle covering them partially, creating the missing segments. Thus, the visual system finds a way to explain the coincidence with an interpretation that it finds acceptable. A similar operation cannot be performed for the palm tree centered between the two hills: the brain tries to interpret the coincidence, but fails, and the result is frustration.


Freely adapted from “The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat,” by V.S. Ramachandran

This is the first installment in a series that explores the “7 rules” of Ramachandran.

Read also